Unable to typeset  PDF Format  Error 

Mental Division Strategy
Task
Jillian says
I know that 20 times 7 is 140 and if I take away 2 sevens that leaves 126. So 126 $\div$ 7 = 18.
 Is Jillian's calculation correct? Explain.
 Draw a picture showing Jillian's reasoning.
 Use Jillian's method to find 222 $\div$ 6.
IM Commentary
This task would be ideal to help students develop mental strategies to think about division during instruction. Jillian's strategy is often referred to as using "compatible numbers." Jillian is using a relationship that she can easily find: 140 divided by 7 is 20 or 20 sets of 7 is 140. The numbers 140 and 7 are often called "compatible" because 14 is a multiple of 7 so Jillian could strategically use this fact to reason through her problem. This task could also be extended to ask students for other mental math strategies to find 126 divided by 7. Students might reason that 10 sets of 7 is 70 and 8 sets of 7 is 56. Since 70 + 56 is 126, there are 18 sets of 7 in the number 126.
Solution

Jillian's reasoning is correct. She has found $20 \times 7 = 140$ and $2 \times 7 = 14$. This means that
\begin{align} 18 \times 7 &= (20  2) \times 7 \\ &= (20 \times 7)  (2 \times 7) \\ &= 140  14 \\ &= 126. \end{align}The second equality uses the distributive property. These equations tell us that 126 $\div$ 7 = 18.

Jillian's initial idea of dividing 140 by 7 is represented here:
From there, Jillian decomposes the 20 sevens into 18 sevens and 2 sevens:
Lastly, Jillian recognizes that if the area of both rectangles combined would be 140, then she must subtract off the 2 extra sevens she used to get 140:

We have $40 \times 6 = 240$ and $3 \times 6 = 18$. So
\begin{align} 37 \times 6 &= (403) \times 6 \\ &= (40 \times 6)  (3 \times 6) \\ &= 240  18 \\ &= 222. \end{align}The second line uses the distributive property of multiplication.
Mental Division Strategy
Jillian says
I know that 20 times 7 is 140 and if I take away 2 sevens that leaves 126. So 126 $\div$ 7 = 18.
 Is Jillian's calculation correct? Explain.
 Draw a picture showing Jillian's reasoning.
 Use Jillian's method to find 222 $\div$ 6.
Comments
Log in to commentCam says:
over 3 yearsI'm struggling to find what part of the argument you find above gradelevel. If you're arguing that students might not have come up with this solution technique (which is maybe plausible, but also differs greatly from classroom to classroom), it might be a good perspective to take that this task could be an introduction to this type of thinking and reasoning!
Kathy says:
over 3 yearsHow many 4th graders truly think this way? I've taught grade 4 students for 5 years and I've yet to have one student who would be able to apply this type of reasoning.