Unable to typeset  PDF Format  Error 

Fractions and Rectangles
Task

What fraction of the rectangle below is shaded?
 Laura says that $\frac14$ of the rectangle is shaded. Do you think she is correct? Explain why or why not by using the picture.
IM Commentary
The primary goal of this task is for students to use pictures to explain the equivalence between $\frac{3}{12}$ and $\frac{1}{4}$. This is a step toward students understanding the general idea that
$$\frac{a\times n}{b\times n} = \frac{a}{b}$$
Students usually first see fraction equivalence by subdividing the pieces into smaller, equal sized pieces and realizing that you haven't changed the amount that represents the fraction. This explains why if you multiply the numerator and denominator by the same whole number, you get an equivalent fraction:
$$\frac{a}{b}=\frac{a\times n}{b\times n}$$
This task helps set students on the path to understanding that if you divide the numerator and denominator by the same whole number, you get an equivalent fraction. It is as if we are "putting smaller pieces together to form bigger pieces," as opposed to subdividing the pieces as seen in, e.g. 4.NF Explaining Fraction Equivalence with Pictures.
Students don't necessarily generate representations like the one shown in the task stem where the pieces are "scattered around," so it is good for them to see and think about such representations.
Attached Resources
Solution

In this picture the entire rectangle has been divided into 12 equalsized pieces. So we can say that each piece is $\frac{1}{12}$ of the entire rectangle. Since 3 out of the total 12 pieces have been shaded, the shaded portion represents
$$\frac{1}{12}+\frac{1}{12}+\frac{1}{12} =3\times \frac{1}{12} = \frac{3}{12}$$
of the total rectangle. We can see the number in the denominator of the fraction represents how many pieces the entire rectangle is broken up into and the numerator represents how many of those pieces are shaded.

Laura is correct. We can see this by simply rearranging the shaded parts of the rectangle to form a single row (See picture below.)
To make it clear that this row represents $\frac14$ of the rectangle we can merge all of the pieces in a row together.
Since the rectangle is now made up of 4 equal sized pieces, the shaded region (which is just one of the four pieces) represents $\frac14$ of the entire rectangle.
Fractions and Rectangles

What fraction of the rectangle below is shaded?
 Laura says that $\frac14$ of the rectangle is shaded. Do you think she is correct? Explain why or why not by using the picture.
Comments
Log in to commentCam says:
over 3 yearsAgreed, both with the specific comment and the general comment on that overused phrase. I also like to use the following example: If you apply the rule "change all the 2's to 3's" to both the top and bottom of a fraction, you can change its value. So "what I did to the top, I did to the bottom" doesn't guarantee an equivalence of fractions. Thanks for the comment!
Sarah says:
over 3 yearsA common error I see with students seeing the notation as a x n/ b x n is the over generalizing when given 1/a x n as 1 x n/a x n. When students looked at the notation as a/b x n/n, we were able to consistently reiterate the use of n/n as equivalent to 1 does not change the value of the fraction, only the "look". Students were more successful at explaining the idea of partitioning the fraction into n pieces (a/b x 1/n) and then needing n pieces to cover the same area as a/(b x n) x n). This helped address the overused phrase of "what I did to the top, I did to the bottom".