Unable to typeset  PDF Format  Error 

JogAThon
Task
Alex is training for his school's JogAThon and needs to run at least $1$ mile per day. If Alex runs to his grandma's house, which is $\frac58$ of a mile away, and then to his friend Justin's house, which is $\frac12$ of a mile away, will he have trained enough for the day?
IM Commentary
The purpose of this task is to present students with a situation where it is natural to add fraction with unlike denominators; it can be used for either assessment or instructional purposes. Teachers should anticipate two types of solutions: one where students calculate the distance Alex ran to determine an answer, and one where students compare the two parts of his run to benchmark fractions.
Actually calculating how far Alex ran illustrates an understanding of the process of adding fractions with unlike denominators. If students take this approach, the teacher should prompt students to show work that clearly indicates the thought process. If students approach the problem by comparing the given fractions to benchmark fractions, the teacher should expect to see less written work. This method requires fraction number sense. Both methods are perfectly reasonable ways to solve this problem, and students should be aware of both methods if this task is used in an instructional setting.
Solutions
Solution: Calculating
First, let's determine how far Alex has run. He ran $\frac58$ of a mile to his grandma’s house, and then $\frac12$ of a mile to Justin’s house. Together, Alex ran $\frac58$ + $\frac12$ miles.
To add fractions, we must have a common denominator for $\frac58$ and $\frac12$. A common denominator of $\frac58$ and $\frac12$ is $8$, so we can use that.
$$\frac12 = \frac{1\times 4}{2\times 4} = \frac48$$
Now that we have a common denominator we can calculate: $$\frac58 + \frac12 = \frac58 + \frac48 = \frac98 = 1 \frac18.$$
In total, Alex ran $1\frac18$ miles. (See Accompanying Images)
Since Alex’s minimum training distance is $1$ mile and he trained more than $1$ mile, the answer is yes; Alex did train enough for the day.

Accompanying Images:
Alex ran $\frac58$ of a mile to his grandma's house and $\frac12$=$\frac48$ of a mile to his friend Justin's house. The picture on the left represents Alex's run to his grandma's house, and the picture on the right represents Alex's run to his friend Justin's house.
By combining the two trips,
we can see that Alex ran $1$ full mile and an additional $\frac18$ of a mile, or $1\frac18$ miles.
Solution: Estimating
To determine whether or not Alex has trained enough for the day we can compare the distance he ran with his minimum training distance. We don't need to calculate the exact distance Alex ran but only whether Alex ran more or less than $1$ mile.
Alex ran $\frac58$ of a mile to his grandma’s house, and we know that
$$\frac58\gt\frac48=\frac12$$
So Alex ran more than half of a mile to his grandma’s house.
He then ran $\frac12$ of a mile to his friend Justin’s house. Since Alex ran more than half of a mile and then an additional half of a mile, we know that he ran more than a full mile. (See Accompanying Images)
Because Alex ran more than his minimum training distance of $1$ mile the answer is yes; Alex has trained enough for the day.

Accompanying Images:
First we will start with a picture representing $1$ mile.
Now we have pictures that represent the portions of a mile that Alex ran on each of his two tips. The picture on the left represents the $\frac58$ of a mile that Alex ran to his grandma's house. The picture on the right represents the $\frac12$ of a mile that Alex ran to his friend Justin's house.
Stacking these images on top of each other, as shown below, makes it easy to see that $\frac58$ > $\frac12$.
By combing the shaded portions, representing the distance Alex actually ran, and comparing this to our original model of $1$ mile,
we can clearly see that Alex ran more than $1$ mile.
JogAThon
Alex is training for his school's JogAThon and needs to run at least $1$ mile per day. If Alex runs to his grandma's house, which is $\frac58$ of a mile away, and then to his friend Justin's house, which is $\frac12$ of a mile away, will he have trained enough for the day?
Comments
Log in to commentAnn Shannon says:
over 1 yearHi I am concerned about the solution to this task—particularly when it says: To add fractions, we must have a common denominator for 5/8 and 1/2. A common denominator of 5/8 and 1/2 is 8, so we can use that. I agree with this reasoning. But the solution goes on to show how to convert 1/2 to 4/8! 1/2 = 1×4/2×4 = 4/8
I found this calculation torturous —most students know that 1/2 is equivalent to 4/8, and would only do the above calculation because someone insists that they AlWAYS show their work! But when the "work" can be done mentally, please let us encourage students to show their smarts. I feel that multiplying 1/2 by 4/4 to give 4/8 shows an alarming lack of basic math. But my point is that the solution presented here sends a really unfortunate meassage.Can I recommend that you rewrite this solution to encourage the use of mental math.
Michael says:
11 monthsWhile I understand your argument, I would suggest allowing the first pass of this activity to rely on number sense as you suggest, but then extending the activity in such a way that nonintuitive fractions are used (e.g. perhaps the friend lives 3/7 of a mile away, such that the approach could expand on quantitative reasoning OR proof by calculation). In the same way that we want students to quickly evaluate various forms of the quantity 1/2, we also want them to understand a few other key concepts here:
1) that multiplying the denominator by a value necessarily decreases the quantity of the fraction and that multiplying the numerator by the same factor necessarily increases the quantity to make the fraction equivalent to its original value.
2) Multiplying a fraction by a second fraction with identical numerator and denominator utilizes the identity property of multiplication (which helps students with informally arguing equivalence)
3) abstract operations in mathematics use fundamental understanding to make calculations more efficient (i.e. at some point, mental math becomes the more tedious approach to solving a problem)