Update all PDFs

Red and Blue Tiles


Alignments to Content Standards: 2.OA.C.3

Task

Lin wants to put some red and blue tiles on a wall for decoration. She is thinking about several different patterns of tiles she could create. She wants to choose a pattern that would let her use exactly as many red tiles as blue tiles.

  1. Is it possible to create the pattern below using the same number of red tiles as blue tiles? Explain.

    Tiles1white_4a0eb6cf71b61e24cc73619f1c020ca8

  2. Is it possible to create the pattern below using the same number of red tiles as blue tiles? Explain.

    Tiles2white_01d95aaf5f81946a60319843fea3d14f

  3. Can you figure out how many tiles are in the pattern below without counting them one by one? Is it possible to create this pattern using the same number of red tiles as blue tiles? Explain.

    Tiles3white_64d301c4854e4e709fdde2fc0c71044a

  4. Of the patterns above, which ones have an even number of tiles? Which ones have an odd number of tiles? If Lin wants to use an equal number of red tiles and blue tiles, should she use a pattern with an even number of tiles, or one with an odd number of tiles? Explain.

IM Commentary

An even number is an integer that is a multiple of 2 while an odd number is an integer that isn't even. In second grade students have not yet learned about multiplication and division (much less factors and multiples), so standard 2.OA.3 calls for students to determine whether a set of objects contains an even or odd number of members using strategies that reflect a grade-appropriate understanding of even and odd. These strategies, such as pairing objects or attempting to divide the objects into two equal subgroups correspond to the "number of groups unknown" and "group size unknown" interpretations of division by 2 that students will study in more depth in third grade.

This task is specifically written so that students have opportunities to use different strategies to determine whether a set has an even or odd number of objects. In particular, part (b) invites students to pair tiles until it is clear that one unpaired tile is left over. Students may suggest using a half of a blue tile and half of a red tile; the teacher should acknowledge that this works if the tiles can be easily broken into two pieces but wouldn't work if not.

In part (c) the tiling arrangement could easily be divided into two equal parts (e.g., the top half and the bottom half). It would be a good idea for the teacher to draw attention to these two different strategies when they are used by the students. In addition, part (c) asks students to determine the number of tiles in an array without counting each tile individually. This can be accomplished using repeated addition, as suggested by 2.OA.4. This foreshadows the introduction of multiplication in third grade.

The reading level for this task may be above that of many second graders, so it is likely that the teacher will need to verbally introduce the task to the students. The figures are intentionally drawn so that students can color the tiles, so it would be good to have red and blue crayons or pencils on hand.

The Standards for Mathematical Practice focus on the nature of the learning experiences by attending to the thinking processes and habits of mind that students need to develop in order to attain a deep and flexible understanding of mathematics. Certain tasks lend themselves to the demonstration of specific practices by students. The practices that are observable during exploration of a task depend on how instruction unfolds in the classroom. While it is possible that tasks may be connected to several practices, only one practice connection will be discussed in depth. Possible secondary practice connections may be discussed but not in the same degree of detail.

This particular task is linked very intentionally to the first part of Mathematical Practice Standard 3, construct viable arguments. Students are asked to explain their thinking about which arrangements of tiles will result in an equal number of blue and red tiles. This type of task lays the foundation for the art of explanation leading to “critiquing the reasoning of others.” Before students can critique the reasoning of others, they must feel comfortable in supporting their own thinking with evidence.  For instance, a second grader might offer the explanation, “I know that the first pattern has an even number of squares because I can pair them up and there are no leftovers. That tells me that there are the same number of blue tiles as red tiles.” The teacher can easily promote a classroom discussion on this argument by asking, “Do you agree and why?” This type of math talk in the classroom is built through collaborative problem solving and dialog.

Solution

This solution uses the language of even and odd even though the task statement does not. For students who are already familiar with that terminology, it would be great if they recognize that it is appropriate here and use it. For students who are not familiar with it, this task provides a great opportunity for teachers to introduce it.

  1. The first arrangement can be divided into two equal parts; for example, we can divide the pattern into the top half and the bottom half. This means that the number of tiles in this arrangement is even.

  2. If we try pairing tiles in the second seating arrangement, we end up with one tile left over. Therefore, the number of tiles in this arrangement is odd.

  3. The tiles in this arrangement are in a 4-by-4 array, so the total number of tiles is 4 + 4 + 4 + 4 = 16. Again, we can divide this arrangement into a top half and a bottom half, so the number of tiles is even.

  4. When the number of tiles is even, Leslie can divide the tiles into two equal-sized groups, one to be made of red tiles and one to be made of blue tiles. She can then create the pattern using an equal number of tiles of each color. When the number of tiles is odd, there will have to be a color (red or blue) that has at least one more tile than the other color. Therefore, Leslie should use a pattern with an even number of tiles if she wants to use the same number of red and blue tiles.

Ken Mullen says:

over 4 years

Here are a couple of suggestions.

The answers to a and b are in terms of odd and even, but that wasn't the way the questions were asked.

The commentary gives a definition of even in terms of division, which the student has not yet gotten to. So, the commentary must be meant for a teacher-reader. But the definition is limited to whole numbers. Shouldn't a teacher have extended this definition to all integers, even if they only teach second grade?

I can see a creative second grader suggesting that one of the squares be filled in with half a red tile and half a blue tile. What about providing guidance for a teacher who has that kind of student?

Kristin says:

over 4 years

Thanks for your suggestions on this task! I agree that the definition of even and odd should be more general in the commentary and updated it. I also added in a comment about the creative second grader who thinks to divide the tiles in half. I think it is appropriate for the solution to use the language of even and odd even though the task statement does not use that language--recognizing a particular mathematical concept describes a given context without explicit prompting from the task statement is the most basic step in the process of modeling with mathematics (MP 4), but added something to this effect in the solution statement to people don't wonder why this choice was made.

Let us know if you have any other suggestions for improving this task!