Update all PDFs

Fruit Salad


Alignments to Content Standards: 6.RP.A.3 6.EE.B.7

Task

A fruit salad consists of blueberries, raspberries, grapes, and cherries. The fruit salad has a total of 280 pieces of fruit. There are twice as many raspberries as blueberries, three times as many grapes as cherries, and four times as many cherries as raspberries. How many cherries are there in the fruit salad?

IM Commentary

The purpose of this task is for students to solve a contextual problem where there is a multiplicative relationship between several quantities in the context. These relationships can either be represented in a ratio table or with a linear equation. Both approaches are valuable and the teacher can link the two by discussing what happens when a variable is used for the number of blueberries in the ratio table. For the algebraic approach, the student is faced with a dilemma: setting the variable equal to the number of cherries leads to a linear equation with fractions while using the number of blueberries as the variable gives a simpler equation. In either case, the students are setting up and solving an equation with positive rational coefficients of the form $px=q$ as described in 6.EE.7.

This task provides opportunities for students to reason about their computations to see if they make sense. A teacher might start out by asking questions like "What is the most common fruit in the salad? What is the least common fruit in the salad?" in order to check that students are reading and interpreting the relationships correctly.

This task was adapted from problem #5 on the 2012 American Mathematics Competition (AMC) 12A Test. For the 2012 AMC 12A, which was taken by 72,238 students, the multiple choice answers for the problem had the following distribution:

Choice Answer Percentage of Answers
(A) 8 2
(B) 16 3
(C) 25 4
(D)* 64 82
(E) 96 2
Omit -- 7

Of the 72,238 students, 28,268 (39%) were in 12th grade, 34,124 (47%) were in 11th grade 4,615 (6%) were in 10th grade and the remainder were below 10th grade.

The Standards for Mathematical Practice focus on the nature of the learning experiences by attending to the thinking processes and habits of mind that students need to develop in order to attain a deep and flexible understanding of mathematics. Certain tasks lend themselves to the demonstration of specific practices by students. The practices that are observable during exploration of a task depend on how instruction unfolds in the classroom. While it is possible that tasks may be connected to several practices, the commentary will spotlight one practice connection in depth. Possible secondary practice connections may be discussed but not in the same degree of detail.

This particular task helps illustrate MP.1.  Students begin by analyzing the problem and looking for entry points to efficiently solve the task.  They may start to create a table or immediately see the relationships between the different fruits and write an expression for how different fruits relate to each other. They might also enter the problem by considering the fruit that is most, or least represented in the salad.  Once an entry point is determined, they monitor and evaluate their progress and change course to a representation that will help them make sense of the problem. To guide students into selecting an entry into this problem and to encourage analysis of their work the teacher might use guiding questions such as: “What do we know?”  “Describe the relationship between the quantities.” “How can we organize the data to better make sense of it?” The ultimate goal of modeling guiding questions is that students will eventually self-question to find a starting point, change direction, or refine their thinking. Once the students solve this task, the teacher may opt to have students discuss in a large group setting how they grappled with the problem, the efficiency and effectiveness of their solution pathway, and if they used strategies from previously solved problems (MP.1, MP.3).

Solutions

Solution: Using a ratio table (6.RP.3)

Below is a table showing different possible amounts of each fruit and the total number of pieces of fruit:

Blueberries RaspberriesCherriesGrapesTotal pieces of fruit
1 2 8 24 35
2 4 16 48 70
4 8 32 96 140
8 16 64 192280

When there are 280 pieces of fruit, there are 64 cherries. Notice that for the table we successively doubled the number of blueberries which also successively doubles the number of pieces of the other fruits. Students may notice, after the second line, that if they quadruple 70, this will give the desired 280 pieces of fruit, making the table a little shorter.

Solution: Writing an equation (6.EE.7)

We are looking for the number of cherries in the fruit salad and will introduce a variable to relate the number of pieces of each fruit. If we let our variable denote the number of cherries then a some work is needed to set up our relationship because the first sentence in the problem deals with blueberries and raspberries. There are twice as many raspberries as blueberries so it is natural to let $x$ denote the number of blueberries. Then we find the following:

Fruit Number of pieces
Blueberries $x$
Raspberries $2x$
Cherries $8x$
Grapes $24x$

Adding up the total number of pieces of fruit gives 35$x$. We have 280 pieces of fruit total so we want to solve $$ 35x = 280. $$ So $x = 280 \div 35 = 8$. There are 8 times as many cherries as blueberries so there are 64 cherries.

Solution: Another way to write the equation (6.EE.7)

Since we are looking for the number of cherries in the fruit salad, it is natural to let $x$ denote the number of cherries.

  • There are 4 times as many cherries as raspberries, so there are $\frac14$ as many raspberries as cherries.
  • There are 2 times as many raspberries as blueberries, so there are $\frac12$ as many blueberries as raspberries. Half of one-fourth is one-eighth, so there are $\frac18$ as many blueberries as cherries.
  • There are 3 times as many grapes as cherries.
We can summarize all of this in a table:

Fruit Number of pieces
Blueberries $\frac18 x$
Raspberries $\frac14 x$
Cherries $x$
Grapes $3x$

Adding up the total number of pieces of fruit gives $4\frac38 x$. We have 280 pieces of fruit total so we want to solve $$ 4\frac38x = 280. $$ So $$x = 280 \div \left(4\frac38\right) = 280 \div \left(\frac{35}{8}\right)= 280 \times \left(\frac{8}{35}\right) = 64.$$ There are 64 cherries in the fruit salad.

Jill says:

5 months

Hey, We used this task with our 6th graders, and I thought I'd share how we anticipated along with how it looked. I wonder if any 6th graders thought about using a spreadsheet.