Update all PDFs
Unable to typeset

PDF Format

Error

Cup of Rice
Alignments to Content Standards:
6.NS.A.1
Task
Tonya and Chrissy are trying to understand the following story problem for $1 \div \frac23$:
One serving of rice is $\frac23$ of a cup. I ate 1 cup of rice. How many servings of rice did I eat?
To solve the problem, Tonya and Chrissy draw a diagram divided into three equal pieces, and shade two of those pieces.
Tonya says, “There is one $\frac23$cup serving of rice in 1 cup, and there is $\frac13$ cup of rice left over, so the answer should be $1 \frac13$.”
Chrissy says, “I heard someone say that the answer is $\frac32 = 1 \frac12$. Which answer is right?”
Is the answer $1 \frac13$ or $1 \frac12$? Explain your reasoning using the diagram.
IM Commentary
One common mistake students make when dividing fractions using visuals is the confusion between remainder and the fractional part of a mixed number answer. In this problem, $\frac13$ is the remainder with units “cups of rice” and $\frac12$ has units “servings”, which is what the problem is asking for.
To see an annotated version of this and other Illustrative Mathematics tasks as well as other Common Core aligned resources, visit Achieve the Core.
Task based on a problem by Sybilla Beckmann, Mathematics for Elementary Teachers, Pearson 2010.
Solution
In Tonya’s solution of $1 \frac13$, she correctly notices that there is one $\frac23$cup serving of rice in 1 cup, and there is $\frac13$ cup of rice left over. But she is mixing up the quantities of servings and cups in her answer. The question becomes how many servings is $\frac13$ cup of rice? The answer is “$\frac13$ cup of rice is $\frac12$ of a serving.”
It would be correct to say, "There is one serving of rice with $\frac13$ cup of rice left over," but to interpret the quotient $1\frac12$, the units for the 1 and the units for the $\frac12$ must be the same:
There are $1\frac12$ servings in 1 cup of rice if each serving is $\frac23$ cup.
Comments
Log in to commentJulie says:
about 4 years(Weird that in preview, comments show up by job title. If it doesn't say my name, I'm Julie Wright.)
I highly recommend this problem. My sixth graders were approximately evenly divided on which was the right answer, and it made for a great discussion. We were able to highlight the correct thinking in the 1 1/3 answer (that it is 1 serving plus 1/3 cup) and find exactly where it broke down. I had the explainer go slowly and we did thumbs up for agreement or thumbs down for disagreement with each statement as we went along. One interesting thing is many of the 1 1/2 answerers disagreed with the statement "The cup of rice is a serving of rice plus an additional 1/3 cup of rice" until we broke down both parts and they realized that statement was true after all.
The pictures were very illuminating as the students talked about their thinking. It might be worth setting up a number line model for this, too.
Cam says:
about 4 yearsAgreed, it is a little weird. On your user profile, there's a little checkbox you can unclick so that it doesn't use this as your descriptor (or you could just change your descriptor to be your name).
Thanks for the feedback on this task!
St. Christopher School says:
about 6 yearsI like the problem in general, but I think it can be improved by changing the wording a bit. In the problem, Tonya says what she thinks the answer is, but Chrissy states that she knows what the answer is supposed to be. The question should not be who is correct between Tonya and Chrissy because the students were working together on the problem and Chrissy indicates that she has gotten the solution from another source. I restated the problem so that Chrissy states that the teacher says the answer is one and onehalf, and the students then question whether the teacher's answer or theirs is the correct one. Or the problem should be reworded so that Chrissy is the source of the alternate answer and then who is correct can be discussed.
Kristin says:
about 6 yearsThanks for pointing that out! I worried that if $1 \frac12$ comes from the teacher, students will think it is correct because the teacher said so rather than for the reasons given in the solution. I did, however, reword it. How does the current formulation work?